Cheese, Butter, Gifts, and Accompaniments

Mt Alice bloomy rind cow's milk cheese Von Trapp Farmstead
Mt Alice
From $18.00
Blake Hill Maple Onion Jam Cheese Pairing Shelburne Farms Cheddar
Blake Hill Maple Onion Jam
$13.00
jar of Blake Hill Caramelized Fig with Pear and Honey Jam
Blake Hill Caramelized Fig with Pear and Honey Jam
$13.00
Cayuga Blue goat's milk cheese Lively Run Dairy
Cayuga Blue
From $21.00
Noblette cow's milk bloomy rind brie-style cheese Calkins Creamery
Noblette
$24.00
St Germain, aged goat's milk cheese Blakesville Creamery
St Germain
From $21.50
Ashbrook ashed cow's milk washed rind cheese Spring Brook Farm
Ashbrook
From $13.50
Small Cheesemonger's Choice
Small Cheesemonger's Choice
$115.00
Pipe dreams buche goat's milk ash rolled cheese Pipe Dreams Fromage
Pipe Dreams Buche
$30.00
Dodge City Salami Smoking Goose Meats
Dodge City Salame
$20.50
Mountaineer alpine cow's milk seasonal cheese Meadow Creek Dairy
Mountaineer
From $18.50
Wine Lover's Box Saxelby Cheese Gifts - Sandy Creek, Calderwood, Appalachian, cow's, goat's milk cheese
Wine Lover's Box
$87.00
Whey Cool Women collection - three women-made cheeses, crackers, and olive tapenade
Whey Cool Women
$133.00
Blake Hill Strawberry Rhubarb Jam Preserve
Blake Hill Strawberry Rhubarb Jam
$13.00
Beer Lover's Box Saxelby Cheese gourmet cheese gift - Shelburne Cheddar, Willoughby, Dunbarton Blue, Effie's Biscuits, Raye's Mustard
Beer Lover's Box
$102.00
Pawlet cow's milk washed rind cheese Woodlawn Creamery
Pawlet
From $17.00
Effie's Homemade Oatcakes Biscuit Crackers
Effie's Oatcakes Crackers
$11.00
Saxelby Cheese Wooden Gift Box cheese gift
Saxelby Wood Gift Box
$29.00
Finger Lakes Gold Reserve goat's milk aged cheese Lively Run Dairy
Finger Lakes Gold Reserve
From $23.00
Regalis Black Truffle Compound Butter
Regalis Black Truffle Butter
$24.00
Quinby bloomy rind brie-style goat's milk cheese Barn First Creamery
Quinby
$12.00
Swallow tail tomme cow's milk natural rind cheese Stony Pond Farm
Swallow Tail Tomme
From $20.00
vonTrapp collection gift set - three organic farmstead cow's milk cheeses from Vermont. Creamery Collection.
von Trapp Farmstead Collection
$90.00
Grass Fed Goodness collection gift set - cow's milk cheese Grayson, Calderwood, Pleasant Ridge Reserve
Grass Fed Goodness
$105.00
Onesto's Sea Salt Crackers, buy gluten free crackers online
Onesto's Gluten Free Sea Salt Crackers
$13.00
Catskill Provisions Wildflower Honey New York
Catskill Provisions Wildflower Honey
$23.00
Rupert cow's milk cheese Woodlawn Creamery
Rupert
From $20.00
Shepsog cow's, sheep's milk natural rind cheese Grafton Village Cheese
Shepsog
From $22.50
Shabby Shoe bloomy rind goat's milk cheese Blakesville Creamery
Shabby Shoe
From $22.00
Baked Brie set gift- a gooey cheese toasted with nuts and strawberry jam with sliced baguettes. cook with this cheese.
Baked Brie Set
$70.00
Nduja Calabrian Pork Salami spread Smoking Goose
Nduja
$18.50
Finocchiona Olympia Provisions Dry Salami
Finocchiona
$16.50
Catskill Provisions Mini Wildflower Honey
Catskill Provisions Mini Wildflower Honey
$6.00
Firefly Farms fresh chevre goat's milk cheese
Firefly Farms Plain Chevre
$6.00
Farmstead Feta sheep's milk cheese Hidden Springs Creamery
Sheep Feta
$14.00
St Malachi cow's milk cheese The Farm at Doe Run
St. Malachi
From $20.00
Marieke Young Gouda cow's milk cheese Hollands Family Cheese
Marieke Young Gouda
From $12.00
Potter's Crackers Caramelized Onion Small Batch Artisan
Potter's Caramelized Onion Crackers
$12.00
Smoking Goose Duck Prosciutto
Duck Prosciutto
$41.00
Blake Hill Apricot with Orange & Honey Jam Cheese Pairing Preserves
Blake Hill Apricot with Orange and Honey Jam
$13.00
Cheese 101 Selection gift set cow's, goat's milk cheese Little Hosmer, Shelburne Cheddar, Finger Lakes Gold
Cheese 101
$79.00
Von Trapp Savage cheese
Savage
From $20.50
Carefully cow's milk cheese Parish Hill Creamery
Carefully
From $19.00
Queso del Invierno Extra Aged cow's, sheep's milk cheese Vermont Shepherd
Invierno Extra-Aged
From $23.00
Ascutney Mountain Reserve cow's milk cheese Cobb Hill Farm
Ascutney Mountain Reserve
From $22.50
Hook's Cheese cow's milk Pepper Jack
Hook's Pepper Jack
$10.00
Seal Cove Plain Classic Chevre goat's milk cheese
Seal Cove Chevre
$12.00
wheel and wedge of Shire cow's milk gouda cheese from Lively Run Dairy
Shire
From $18.00
Leading Ladies selection of cow's, goat's milk cheeses - Marieke Premium Gouda, St Germain, Mini Kunik, Boucher Blue, Swallow Tail Tomme. Cheesemongers pick.
Leading Ladies
$123.00
Boucher Blue cow's milk Green Mountain Blue Cheese
Boucher Blue
From $16.50 Sold out
Snow Camp cow's milk bloomy rind cheese Goat Lady Dairy
Snow Camp
$15.00 Sold out
Grilling Cheese Halloumi cow's milk Narragansett Creamery
Grilling Cheese
$9.00 Sold out
Thin Red Line goat's milk ashed bloomy rind cheese Lazy Lady Farm
Thin Red Line
$15.00 Sold out
Pleasant Ridge Reserve Extra Aged cow's milk alpine Upland's Cheese
Pleasant Ridge Reserve Extra Aged
From $23.50 Sold out
Sherry Gray - a double cream ash-ripened cow's milk cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Sherry Gray
$22.50 Sold out
Ricotta Salata Vecchio cow's milk cheese Caputo
Ricotta Salata Vecchio
From $8.00 Sold out
Middlebury Blue cow's milk blue cheese natural rind Blue Ledge Farm
Middlebury Blue
From $12.50 Sold out
Hooligan washed rind stinky cow's milk cheese Cato Corner Farm
Hooligan
From $28.00 Sold out
Rupert Reserve cow's milk extra aged cheese
Rupert Reserve
From $21.00 Sold out
Triple Cream Dream
Triple Cream Dream
$83.00 Sold out
Mitica Italian Sliced Prosciutto
Mitica Prosciutto Pre-Sliced
$12.50 Sold out
34 Degrees Original Crisps Crackers
34 Degrees Crackers
$12.00 Sold out
Camembrie cow's milk bloomy rind brie camembert-style cheese Blue Ledge Farm
Camembrie
$14.00 Sold out
Mountain Top
Mountain Top
$13.00 Sold out
Cheddar Cheese cow's milk curds Boston Post Dairy
Cheddar Cheese Curds
$13.00 Sold out
Eligo cow's, goat's milk washed rind cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Eligo
From $22.00 Sold out
Sandy Creek goat's milk ashed bloomy rind cheese Goat Lady Dairy
Sandy Creek
$20.00 Sold out
Seal Cove Maine Dill & Garlic Chevre goat's milk cheese
Seal Cove Dill and Garlic Chevre
$12.00 Sold out
Moses Reaper cow's milk ashed bloomy rind halloween cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Moses Reaper
$34.00 Sold out
Potter's Crackers Six Seed Small Batch Artisan
Potter's Six Seed Crackers
$12.00 Sold out
Raye's Mustard Old World Gourmet Small Batch Stone Ground European Style
Old World Gourmet Mustard
$14.00 Sold out
Seal Cove Maine Herbed Chevre goat's milk cheese
Seal Cove Herbed Chevre
$12.00 Sold out

Follow @saxelbycheese

© 2026 Saxelby Cheesemongers | Art Direction by Alexandra Hammond