Carefully

Parish Hill Creamery

Carefully cow's milk cheese Parish Hill Creamery
$19.00 Sale

 The expert cheesemakers at Parish Hill are always tinkering and innovating, and often, those things lead to phenomenal results! Carefully began as an experiment to satiate their desire to make a version of the Welsh cheese, Caerphilly. Clearly, they thought their version was a success, and now we can bring their time-honed experiment to you! 

A cousin of cheddar, this milled-curd cow’s milk cheese is robust, tart, and bright, with a creamy texture when it’s young, and a drier, flakier texture when it matures. Closer to the rind, see if you can pinpoint notes of freshly roasted peanuts and fried chicken skin that contrast the acidic paste beneath.


Cheese Care

You may also love

Olive Oil and Sea Salt Crackers The Fine Cheese Co
Olive Oil and Sea Salt Crackers
$13.00
Potter's Classic White Crackers Small Batch Artisan
Potter's Classic White Crackers
$12.00
Rust Belt Saucisson Smoking Goose Meats
Rust Belt Saucisson
$20.50
Verano sheep's milk natural rind cheese Vermont Shepherd
Verano
From $25.00
Appalachian cow's milk alpine seasonal cheese Meadow Creek Dairy
Appalachian
From $18.00
Queso del Invierno sheep's, cow's milk natural rind cheese Vermont Shepherd
Invierno
From $19.00 Sold out

Customer Reviews

Based on 3 reviews
100%
(3)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
M
Margaret Parsons
Awesome cheeses -- beautifully presented, what a find!

Recently I discovered Saxelby and decided to try their cheeses, so selected four, along with a delicious caramelized fig spread and some crackers. When I opened the box I was thrilled with the whole experience. Even the papers the cheeses are wrapped in are the best! Lovely experience.

P
Paula Woods
Carefully

Reminds me of Welsh cheese I got in Wales. Nice and crumbly with good sharpish flavor.

R
Rachael Dwyer
The Big Cheese

I ordered a great selection of American cheeses from the east coast. They are all unique and flavourful. I loved the paper used to wrap them as well and the labels and included sheet with the description of each cheese - very classy. Highly recommend.

Follow @saxelbycheese

© 2025 Saxelby Cheesemongers | Art Direction by Alexandra Hammond