Cheese, Butter, Gifts, and Accompaniments

Cabot Clothbound Cheddar Cheese cow's milk Jasper Hill Farm
Cabot Clothbound Cheddar
From $17.00
Ploughgate Creamery Cultured Butter Salted 8oz
Ploughgate Creamery Cultured Butter, 8oz salted
$15.00
Bayley Hazen Blue Cheese cow's milk Jasper Hill Farm
Bayley Hazen Blue
From $18.00
Nancy's Camembert cow's, sheep's milk brie-style bloomy rind cheese Old Chatham Creamery
Nancy's Camembert
From $16.50
Calderwood cow's milk hay coated alpine cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Calderwood
From $18.00
Parmigiano Reggiano imported Italian culinary cheese Mitica
Parmigiano Reggiano
From $16.50
Shelburne Two Year Cheddar cow's milk aged cheese Shelburne Farms
Shelburne Two Year Cheddar
From $14.00
Olive Oil and Sea Salt Crackers The Fine Cheese Co
Olive Oil and Sea Salt Crackers
$13.00
Kunik Mini goat's, cow's milk cheese bloomy rind ripened cheese Nettle Meadow Farm
Kunik
From $13.00
Ploughgate Creamery Cultured Butter Unsalted 8oz
Ploughgate Creamery Cultured Butter, 8oz unsalted
$15.00
Ascutney Mountain cow's milk natural rind cheese Cobb Hill Farm
Ascutney Mountain
From $20.00
Red Rock cow's milk blue cheddar cheese Roelli Cheese Haus
Red Rock
From $18.50
Ploughgate Creamery Cultured Butter Salted 1lb
Ploughgate Creamery Cultured Butter, 1lb salted
$27.00
American Cheese Society Winners Trio gift set - Calderwood, Finger Lakes Gold, Noblette cow's milk, goat's milk
American Cheese Society Winners Trio
$85.00
Burrata fresh cow's milk cheese Narragansett Creamery
Burrata
$13.00
Potter's Classic White Crackers Small Batch Artisan
Potter's Classic White Crackers
$12.00
Jake's Gouda cow's milk wax rind cheese
Jake's Gouda
From $15.50
Spring Brook Farm Taentaise Reserve aged alpine cow's milk cheese
Spring Brook Tarentaise Reserve
From $25.50
American Cheese Society Winners Quintet gift set - Calderwood, Mad River Blue, Ashbrook, Finger Lakes Gold, Noblette cow's milk, goat's milk
American Cheese Society Winners Quintet
$125.00
Saxelby Cheesemongers Artisan Butter Collection gift Ploughgate Cultured Butter, High Lawn Farm Sweet Cream Butter, Regalis Black Truffle Butter
Artisan Butter Collection
$60.00
Moses Sleeper brie-style cow's milk bloomy rind cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Moses Sleeper
$34.00
Pleasant Ridge Reserve cow's milk alpine cheese Upland's
Pleasant Ridge Reserve
From $19.50
High Lawn Farm cow's milk sea salted butter 8oz
High Lawn Farm Butter, 8oz Sea Salted
$16.00
Oma cow's milk washed rind organic cheese von Trapp Farmstead
Oma
From $21.00
Fresh cow's milk mozzarella cheese Narragansett Creamery
Fresh Mozzarella
$6.00
Finger Lakes Gold goat's milk gouda cheese Lively Run Dairy
Finger Lakes Gold
From $20.00
High Lawn Farm Sweet Cream cow's milk butter 8oz
High Lawn Farm Butter, 8oz Sweet Cream
$16.00
Alpha Tolman cow's milk alpine cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Alpha Tolman
From $17.00
Cheese & Charcuterie selection gift set - Jake's Gouda, Bayley Hazen Blue, Cabot Clothbound Cheddar, Saucisson Sec, Mitica Prosciutto, Artisan Crackers
Cheese and Charcuterie
$125.00
Lake's Edge bloomy rind ashed goat's milk cheese Blue Ledge Farm
Lake's Edge
From $20.00
Reading Raclette cow's milk washed rind cheese Spring Brook Farm
Reading Raclette
From $13.00
Verano sheep's milk natural rind cheese Vermont Shepherd
Verano
From $25.00
Maple Smoked Cheddar Cow's Milk Cheese Grafton Village Cheese
Maple Smoked Cheddar
From $11.50
Salty Sea Feta cow's milk cheese Narragansett Creamery
Salty Sea Feta
$6.50
Marieke Premium Gouda cow's milk cheese Hollands Family Cheese
Marieke Premium Gouda
From $16.00
Appalachian cow's milk alpine seasonal cheese Meadow Creek Dairy
Appalachian
From $18.00
large cheesemonger's choice cheese gift box - a selection of five different cheeses with honey, jam, and crackers, cow's, goat's, sheep's milk cheese. Cheesemongers pick.
Large Cheesemonger's Choice
$160.00
The New Rules of Cheese, a book that will teach you how to serve cheese, make cheese plates, and the fundamentals of how cheese is made from cheesemonger Anne Saxelby
The New Rules of Cheese
$14.99
Renaissance Ricotta fresh cow's milk cheese Narragansett Creamery
Renaissance Ricotta
$8.00
american cheddar flight - four different kinds of cheddar cheese on a cheese board with honey and figs
American Cheddar Flight
$95.00
Best Sellers Box selection cheese gift set - Ascutney Mountain, Bayley Hazen Blue, Shelburne Cheddar, Nancy's Camembert, Mitica Prosciutto, Potter's Classic White Crackers. Cheesemongers pick.
Best Sellers Box
$130.00
Spring Brook Tarentaise natural rind alpine cheese Spring Brook Farm
Spring Brook Tarentaise
From $18.00
Pecorino Romano DOP Italian sheep's milk cooking cheese
Pecorino Romano
From $15.00
Marieke Truffle Gouda cow's milk Hollands Family Cheese
Marieke Truffle Gouda
From $16.00
Jasper Hill Farm Collection - a collection of five cheeses from Jasper Hill Farm in Vermont. Creamery Collection.
Jasper Hill Farm Collection
$132.00
Rust Belt Saucisson Smoking Goose Meats
Rust Belt Saucisson
$20.50
Saxelby Cheese Online Gift Card Certificate
Gift Card
From $50.00
Merry Goat Round Spruce Reserve bark wrapped goat's milk cheese Firefly Farms
Merry Goat Round Spruce Reserve
$26.00
Buy 1841 Havarti cheese online cow's milk gouda Calkins Creamery
1841 Havarti
From $12.00
Perfect grilled cheese kit Saxelby Cheese culinary gift set - Reading Raclette, Shelburne Cheddar, High Lawn Farm Sea Salted Butter. Cook with this cheese.
The Perfect Grilled Cheese Kit
$76.00
Wischago aged sheep's milk cheese Hidden Springs Creamery
Wischago
From $19.50
Dunbarton Blue Cheddar Cheese cow's milk Roelli Cheese Haus
Dunbarton Blue
From $21.50
Jake's 3 Year Cheddar sharp cow's milk cheese
Jake's 3 Year Cheddar
From $15.00
Cabot Clothbound Cheddar cow's milk cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Black Label Cabot Clothbound
From $19.00
Saxelby Cheese Paper
Saxelby Cheese Paper
$5.00
Noble Road cow's milk bloomy rind brie-style cheese Calkins Creamery
Noble Road
From $34.00
Queso del Invierno sheep's, cow's milk natural rind cheese Vermont Shepherd
Invierno
From $19.00
Hook's Blue cow's milk cheese
Hook's Blue
From $12.00
Willoughby washed rind cow's milk cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Willoughby
$19.00
Bohemian Blue sheep's milk cheese Hidden Springs Creamery
Bohemian Blue
From $20.00
Whitney washed rind alpine cow's milk cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Whitney
From $17.00
Ewe Calf to Be Kidding cow's, goat's, sheep's milk blue cheese Hook's Cheese
Ewe Calf to Be Kidding
From $16.00
Vault 5 Cheddar cows milk cheese Cabot Creamery, Cellars at Jasper Hill Farm
Vault 5 Cheddar
From $12.00
Mad River Blue Cheese cow's milk von Trapp Farmstead
Mad River Blue
From $20.50
Cowles ashed bloomy rind goat's milk cheese Barn First Creamery
Cowles
$22.00
Saucisson Sec Dry Salami Olympia Provisions
Saucisson Sec
$16.50
Tres Bonne goat's milk gouda cheese Boston Post Dairy
Tres Bonne
From $22.00
Harbison bark wrapped bloomy rind cow's milk gooey cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Harbison
$25.00 Sold out
Winnimere bark wrapped cow's milk seasonal cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Winnimere
$35.00 Sold out
Grayson washed rind seasonal cow's milk cheese Meadow Creek Dairy
Grayson
From $20.00 Sold out
Rush Creek Reserve bark wrapped seasonal cow's milk cheese Upland's
Rush Creek Reserve
$45.00 Sold out
Mini Harbison bark wrapped cow's milk bloomy rind cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Mini Harbison
$15.00 Sold out

Follow @saxelbycheese

© 2026 Saxelby Cheesemongers | Art Direction by Alexandra Hammond