Find Artisanal Cheese & Buy Cheese Online | Saxelby Cheese

Our top cheeses

Unforgettable selections from small farms and creameries Shop bestsellers

The Saxelby Cheese Club

Discover new artisan cheeses each month! Join Today

Let us cater your next event

Available for local NYC delivery Build your own cheese board

The Best in American Cheese

Best Sellers Box selection cheese gift set - Ascutney Mountain, Bayley Hazen Blue, Shelburne Cheddar, Nancy's Camembert, Mitica Prosciutto, Potter's Classic White Crackers. Cheesemongers pick.

Best Sellers Box

american cheddar flight - four different kinds of cheddar cheese on a cheese board with honey and figs

American Cheddar Flight

Perfect grilled cheese kit Saxelby Cheese culinary gift set - Reading Raclette, Shelburne Cheddar, High Lawn Farm Sea Salted Butter. Cook with this cheese.

The Perfect Grilled Cheese Kit

American Cheese Society Winners Quintet gift set - Calderwood, Mad River Blue, Ashbrook, Finger Lakes Gold, Noblette cow's milk, goat's milk

American Cheese Society Winners Quintet

Culinary collection cheese gift set Parmigiano Reggiano, Aged Cheddar, Reading Raclette, High Lawn Farm Butter. cook with this cheese.

Culinary Collection

Cheese 101 Selection gift set cow's, goat's milk cheese Little Hosmer, Shelburne Cheddar, Finger Lakes Gold

New Arrivals to Our Cheese Cave

Truffle Shuffle

Truffle Shuffle

From $27.00 Sold out

Yearling Appalachian

Yearling Appalachian

From $24.00 Sold out

Black Squares Crackers

Black Squares Crackers

Duet Gouda

Saucisson d'Alsace

Saucisson d'Alsace

Emerson Farmer's Cheese spread on crispy bread. Fresh cow's milk cheese from Woodlawn Creamery.

Saxelby's Cheese Clubs

saxelby cheesemongers cheese of the month club gift - a selection of three cheeses. Cheesemongers pick.

Monthly Cheese Club

Saxelby Cheesemongers Connoisseur's Club quarterly subscription box gift. Cheesemongers pick.

Connoisseur's Club

selection of cheeses, Fine & Raw chocolate bars

Cheese & Chocolate Club

Bestsellers

Cabot Clothbound Cheddar Cheese cow's milk Jasper Hill Farm

Cabot Clothbound Cheddar

Ploughgate Creamery Cultured Butter Salted 8oz

Ploughgate Creamery Cultured Butter, 8oz salted

Bayley Hazen Blue Cheese cow's milk Jasper Hill Farm

Bayley Hazen Blue

Nancy's Camembert cow's, sheep's milk brie-style bloomy rind cheese Old Chatham Creamery

Nancy's Camembert

Calderwood cow's milk hay coated alpine cheese Jasper Hill Farm

From $18.00 Sold out

Parmigiano Reggiano imported Italian culinary cheese Mitica

Parmigiano Reggiano

Artisan Cheese From Small American Farms

All-Star Accompaniments

A 5-Minute History of American Cheese

Gifts Under $100

Beautiful Artisan Butter

Animal Farm cultured butter Vermont

Animal Farm Cultured Butter

$60.00 Sold out

Ploughgate Creamery Cultured Butter Salted 8oz

Ploughgate Creamery Cultured Butter, 8oz salted

High Lawn Farm Sweet Cream cow's milk butter 8oz

High Lawn Farm Butter, 8oz Sweet Cream

Meet Our Producers

Get to know the people (and animals!) behind your favorite cheese.

Farm Profiles on Our Blog

Get cheesy with us!

Sign up for our weekly emails for promotions and insider info on cheese, farms and all things Saxelby.

Follow @saxelbycheese

© 2026 Saxelby Cheesemongers | Art Direction by Alexandra Hammond