It's our 20th anniversary! Save 20% with code 20YEARS today only.

It's our 20th anniversary! Save 20% with code 20YEARS today only.

Raw Milk Cheeses

Bayley Hazen Blue Cheese cow's milk Jasper Hill Farm
Bayley Hazen Blue
From $19.00
Calderwood cow's milk hay coated alpine cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Calderwood
From $19.00
Parmigiano Reggiano imported Italian culinary cheese Mitica
Parmigiano Reggiano
From $16.50
Shelburne Two Year Cheddar cow's milk aged cheese Shelburne Farms
Shelburne Two Year Cheddar
From $14.00
Ascutney Mountain cow's milk natural rind cheese Cobb Hill Farm
Ascutney Mountain
From $20.00
Jake's Gouda cow's milk wax rind cheese
Jake's Gouda
From $15.50
Spring Brook Farm Taentaise Reserve aged alpine cow's milk cheese
Spring Brook Tarentaise Reserve
From $25.50
Pleasant Ridge Reserve cow's milk alpine cheese Upland's
Pleasant Ridge Reserve
From $19.50
Alpha Tolman cow's milk alpine cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Alpha Tolman
From $18.00
Reading Raclette cow's milk washed rind cheese Spring Brook Farm
Reading Raclette
From $13.00
Verano sheep's milk natural rind cheese Vermont Shepherd
Verano
From $25.00
Maple Smoked Cheddar Cow's Milk Cheese Grafton Village Cheese
Maple Smoked Cheddar
From $11.50
Marieke Premium Gouda cow's milk cheese Hollands Family Cheese
Marieke Premium Gouda
From $16.00
Appalachian cow's milk alpine seasonal cheese Meadow Creek Dairy
Appalachian
From $18.00
Buy 1841 Havarti cheese online cow's milk gouda Calkins Creamery
1841 Havarti
From $12.00
Jake's 3 Year Cheddar sharp cow's milk cheese
Jake's 3 Year Cheddar
From $15.00
Wischago aged sheep's milk cheese Hidden Springs Creamery
Wischago
From $19.50
Queso del Invierno sheep's, cow's milk natural rind cheese Vermont Shepherd
Invierno
From $19.00
Whitney washed rind alpine cow's milk cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Whitney
From $17.00
Marieke Overjarige Aged Gouda cow's milk cheese Hollands Family Cheese
Marieke Overjarige Gouda
From $18.00
Marieke Smoked cow's milk gouda Hollands Family Cheese
Marieke Smoked Gouda
From $13.00
Boucher Blue cow's milk Green Mountain Blue Cheese
Boucher Blue
From $16.50
Ashbrook ashed cow's milk washed rind cheese Spring Brook Farm
Ashbrook
From $13.50
Hooligan washed rind stinky cow's milk cheese Cato Corner Farm
Hooligan
From $28.00
Mountaineer alpine cow's milk seasonal cheese Meadow Creek Dairy
Mountaineer
From $18.50
Pawlet cow's milk washed rind cheese Woodlawn Creamery
Pawlet
From $17.00
Swallow tail tomme cow's milk natural rind cheese Stony Pond Farm
Swallow Tail Tomme
From $20.00
Rupert cow's milk cheese Woodlawn Creamery
Rupert
From $20.00
Shepsog cow's, sheep's milk natural rind cheese Grafton Village Cheese
Shepsog
From $22.50
Marieke Young Gouda cow's milk cheese Hollands Family Cheese
Marieke Young Gouda
From $12.00
Carefully cow's milk cheese Parish Hill Creamery
Carefully
From $19.00
Queso del Invierno Extra Aged cow's, sheep's milk cheese Vermont Shepherd
Invierno Extra-Aged
From $23.00
Ascutney Mountain Reserve cow's milk cheese Cobb Hill Farm
Ascutney Mountain Reserve
From $22.50
Womanchego cow's milk cheese Cato Corner Farm
Womanchego
From $22.00
Great Hill Blue cow's milk cheese Great Hill Dairy
Great Hill Blue
From $14.00
Withersbrook Blue cow's milk ice cider cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Withersbrook Blue
From $19.50
Reverie cow's milk cheese Parish Hill Creamery
Reverie
From $20.00
Vampire Slayer cow's milk cheese garlic & spices Calkins Creamery
Vampire Slayer
From $12.50
Humble cow's milk cheese Parish Hill Creamery
Humble
From $19.00
Jack's Blue cow's milk cheese Parish Hill Creamery
Jack's Blue
From $19.50
washed rind cow's milk Black Capped Cache cheese Stony Pond Farm
Black Capped Cache
From $21.00
Madison
Madison
From $16.50
Gore-Dawn-Zola
Gore-Dawn-Zola
From $16.50
Yearling Appalachian
Yearling Appalachian
From $24.00
Suncatcher
Suncatcher
From $12.75
Shelburne Beer Cheddar
Shelburne Beer Cheddar
$17.00
Oxbow
Oxbow
From $17.00
Winnimere bark wrapped cow's milk seasonal cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Winnimere
$36.00 Sold out
Grayson washed rind seasonal cow's milk cheese Meadow Creek Dairy
Grayson
From $20.00 Sold out
Rush Creek Reserve bark wrapped seasonal cow's milk cheese Upland's
Rush Creek Reserve
$45.00 Sold out
Pleasant Ridge Reserve Extra Aged cow's milk alpine Upland's Cheese
Pleasant Ridge Reserve Extra Aged
From $23.50 Sold out
Rupert Reserve cow's milk extra aged cheese
Rupert Reserve
From $21.00 Sold out
Bayley Hazen Blue Black Label cow's milk cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Black Label Bayley Hazen Blue
From $22.00 Sold out
Bloomsday natural rind cow's milk cheese Cato Corner Farm
Bloomsday
From $22.00 Sold out
Aged Bloomsday cow's milk cheese Cato Corner Farm
Aged Bloomsday
From $24.00 Sold out
Black Label Alpha Tolman cow's milk alpine cheese Jasper Hill Farm
Black Label Alpha Tolman
From $21.00 Sold out

Follow @saxelbycheese

© 2026 Saxelby Cheesemongers | Art Direction by Alexandra Hammond